[75] Complying with the Supervision Guidelines is, without doubt, a big job and the deadline for compliance is fast approaching. 10.10 Acres Located on Squires Rd., [37] Justice Department Seeks Forfeiture of Third Commercial Property Purchased with Funds Misappropriated from PrivatBank in Ukraine, Press Release, Department of Justice (Dec. 30, 2020), Advisory to Financial Institutions and Real Estate Firms and Professionals, Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, FIN-2017-A003 (Aug. 22, 2017). These areas are: (1) The Texas counties of Bexar (includes San Antonio), Tarrant, and Dallas; (2) the Florida counties of Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach; (3) all New York City boroughs: Brooklyn, Queens, Bronx, Staten Island, and Manhattan; (4) the California counties of San Diego, Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Mateo, and Santa Clara; (5) the City and County of Honolulu in Hawaii; (6) the Nevada county of Clark (includes Las Vegas); (7) the Washington county of King (includes Seattle); (8) the Massachusetts counties of Suffolk and Middlesex (includes Boston and Cambridge, respectively); and (9) the Illinois county of Cook (includes Chicago). 34. 2018) (several transactions under $20,000); United States You cant afford to leave it to the last minute. Ct. App. United States Typical closing transactions may involve several participants, performing distinct, but complementary, functions, in addition to the buyer and seller. For the purposes of the 2016 Real Estate GTO, legal entity meant a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, or other similar business entity, whether formed under the laws of a state or of the United States or a foreign jurisdiction. Learn more here. 16. 3 . I tried. As previously noted, other businesses and professions involved in real estate transactions, such as real estate brokers and agents, title company representatives, and closing agents (including attorneys when involved), currently are not subject to AML/CFT reporting obligations, and some of these, such as title insurance and real estate agents, are not mandatory in many transactions. 6, 1937, ch. An Act to provide for the regulation of property and stock agents; to repeal the Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 1941; and for other purposes. FinCEN solicits comments, however, on whether a minimum threshold should be included. See, e.g., Aug. 6, 2020). amount for the reporting threshold for transactions? Summary of August 2021 Existing Home Sales Statistics, National Association of Realtors (Sep. 22, 2021). . 38. Check them out. Bradley, 2011). If you are a member sign into update your communication preferences to ensure you don't miss an update. See The President of the United States manages the operations of the Executive branch of Government through Executive orders. See generally e.g., 69, 6, as added May . containing beneficial ownership requirements, would affect the real estate industry. 386 F. Supp. Since 2016, and most recently in October 2021, FinCEN has renewed the Real Estate GTOs multiple times (collectively, the Real Estate GTO program) and made modifications to their terms to address perceived gaps in the data collected. FinCEN is particularly interested in comment concerning the volume and/or type of money laundering vulnerabilities associated with commercial and with residential real estate, and any unique factors or complexities regarding non-financed transactions in each segment, to enable FinCEN to assess appropriate regulatory treatment for residential and commercial real estate purchases. 41. 81. v. Definitions 3A. Describe the potential money laundering and illicit finance risks and vulnerabilities arising in the U.S. real estate market. The prospectus of debut Eurobonds of the Development Bank of the Republic of Belaru What specific requirements in these regulations do you expect may have the greatest impact on your operations? 8. v. United States While a PDF of the Manual can be downloaded and printed, REINSW does not recommend it. 20-cv-02071, Doc. trailer << /Size 29 /Info 9 0 R /Encrypt 14 0 R /Root 13 0 R /Prev 16444 /ID[] >> startxref 0 %%EOF 13 0 obj << /Pages 10 0 R /Type /Catalog /Metadata 11 0 R >> endobj 14 0 obj << /Filter /Standard /R 2 /O ( UV.`Dz-#_m_}g) /U (^>28j'2WURk@) /P -60 /V 1 /Length 40 >> endobj 27 0 obj << /S 80 /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 28 0 R >> stream 64. [25] v. Document Drafting Handbook Treasury Order 180-01 (Jan. 14, 2020). Redfin.com The Property and Stock Agents Act 2002 reforms which came into effect on 23rd March 2020, brought with them the revised Supervision Guidelines which extend upon the previous obligations on a licensee that arise from section 32 of the Act. According to this report, these PEPs used a network of shell companies to move funds abroad and purchase millions of dollars of real estate, including 17 properties for a total of $6.6 million in Washington, DC, and Johannesburg, South Africa. 79. Section 55 of the Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002 (NSW) ("the Act") requires that a written agency agreement must be prepared for all services to be performed by an agent for a client if the agent wishes to claim a commission. These individuals were sometimes another member of the criminal organization but were often a family member or personal associate of the criminal.[71] DOJ actions have exposed, for example, drug trafficking organizations funneling illicit proceeds into an investment firm and then using the proceeds to invest in commercial real estate ventures,[67] For example, in February 2015, Licensees who operate a real estate business have a duty to properly supervise that business. Are these risks different for the residential and commercial real estate sectors? 56. 2:18-cr-00103-RDP-JEO, Doc. 31 U.S.C. Lastly, real estate transactions involving purchases by publicly traded companies have been exempted.[57]. 03/01/2023, 205 Does this differ for residential and commercial real estate? From VOLVO, BMW and OFFICEWORKS 62. FinCEN notes that recent high profile DOJ enforcement actions, including a forfeiture action to recover an alleged $3.5 million in corrupt proceeds laundered through the purchase of a Potomac, Maryland, mansion via a trust, indicate that consideration of any proposed rule should also include the risks presented by U.S. and foreign trusts.[81]. 32. Is the decision to use real estate brokers, or agents, or attorneys different for all-cash real estate transactions? date of sale, location of property, sale price, and any other terms or conditions); (iv) the source of funds; (v) the form of payments ( 54. 0000002467 00000 n 1:19CR390, Doc. Politically Exposed PersonsOverview, FFIEC BSA/AML Examination Manual, p. 290 (V5 2015); 5316(a)(1)(requirement to report importing or exporting monetary instruments of more than $10,000 at one time); 31 CFR 1010.330(a)(requirement to report receipt of currency in excess of $10,000 in the course of trade or business). Based on the NAR estimates of total home sales and median sale prices, this means that approximately 1.21 million residential real estate transactions, with an approximate value of $463 billion, likely proceed without any AML reporting obligations. 31 U.S.C. FinCEN invites comments regarding the approach that it should take with respect to regulatory treatment of residential and commercial real estate and the money laundering threats presented by these sectors. Section 154, acts Aug. 20, 1912, ch. Many comments suggested that the threat of money laundering through real estate warranted appropriate regulation, but commenters disagreed over the specific businesses that should be covered. the material on FederalRegister.gov is accurately displayed, consistent with Start Printed Page 69601 FinCEN is considering proposing such a rule that would apply throughout the United States and would contain no lower reporting dollar threshold. Should trusts be covered? 5318(h)(1)-(2). In later Real Estate GTOs, FinCEN excluded from the definition of legal entity any entity for which the shares are publicly traded on a U.S. stock exchange. documents in the last year, 522 Such a specific reporting requirement could be imposed under 31 U.S.C. Case No. Generally, the Census Bureau tracks new home sales, while the most accurate data for existing home sales is generated by NAR. Moreover, the study found that the use of anonymous shell companies and complex corporate structures continue[d] to be the number one money laundering typology involving real estate. 29, 2018) (purchase of multiple properties in Alabama); However, while there are certainly many similarities in terms of policies and procedures from agency to agency, there will also be some differences. REINSW offers training subsidised by the NSW Government: Describe a typical commercial real estate transaction. United States Form 10-K (annual report [section 13 and 15(d), not s-k item 405]) filed with the SEC Section 52 of Property and Stock Agents Act (NSW) 2002 establishes a list of 'material facts' that an agent must disclose. Please explain how payment is most often tendered for real estate purchases ( Section 148e, act Apr. 51. In contrast, FinCEN's GTOs have subjected title insurance companies in the non-financed real estate market to a more specific reporting requirement applicable to all covered transactions. Start Printed Page 69600 The Real Estate GTOs required title insurance companies to file reports and maintain records concerning all-cash purchases of residential real estate above a certain threshold in select metropolitan areas of the United States. v. With this ANPRM, FinCEN seeks input on how it should implement such a system, consistent with the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA), to maximize benefits while minimizing burdens on reporting financial institutions and nonfinancial trades or businesses. 5318(a)(2), as amended by Section 6102(a) of the AML Act, which authorizes the Secretary to "require a class of domestic financial institutions . How should the term persons involved in real estate closings and settlements be defined? Bradley, FinCEN invites the views of real estate businesses and professionals, trade organizations, law enforcement, federal agencies, state, local, and Tribal governments, NGOs, members of civil society, and any other interested parties. See REINSW has written the Manual to respond to the compliance needs of the majority of agencies. The Real Estate GTOs initially required some of the largest title insurance companies in the United States to report beneficial ownership[49] The articles identified a specific set of real estate transactions as a high potential money laundering risk: The use of shell companies to pay for residential properties in cash at the time of closing, without a corresponding mortgage. 653 F.3d 729 (8th Cir. . The Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002 is the primary legislation that administers the conduct of real estate agents and property industry professionals. United States Skip to content. 31. How do due diligence processes, if any, differ for commercial or residential properties? FinCEN encourages commenters to reference specific question numbers to facilitate FinCEN's review of comments. Should the rules be structured to require collection of information about only the most vulnerable or high-risk transactions? . 5326). F. What are the potential burdens or implementation costs of a potential FinCEN regulation? see also v. [66] 46. 36. Do you anticipate being able to integrate implementation costs into your existing compliance-related budget? This topic provides an overview of an employee and supervisor's obligations under the Property and Stock Agents Act 2002 and Property and Stock Agents Regulation 2014. The 2016 GTO defined Covered Transactions as transactions involving a covered business where: (i) A legal entity; (ii) purchased residential real property; (iii) located in the Borough of Manhattan in NY, or Miami-Dade County in Florida; (iv) for a total purchase price of $1,000,000 or more in Miami, or $3,000,000 or more in Manhattan; (v) the purchase was made without a bank loan or other similar financing; and (vi) the purchase was made, at least in part, using a monetary instrument ( This PDF is Clarification of the central themes of Ned Block's article "The Harder Problem of Consciousness." In particular, explains why Block thinks that the question of whether a certain kind of robot is phenomenally conscious is relevant to the question of what phenomenal consciousness essentially is, that is, with what, if anything, it can be identified in terms of natural properties investigated . https://gfintegrity.org/press-release/new-report-finds-u-s-real-estate-sector-a-safe-haven-for-money-laundering/. For certain categories of financial institutions, FinCEN has included explicit requirements to conduct customer due diligence and to identify and verify the identity of beneficial owners of legal entity customers, subject to certain exclusions and conditions. The report further noted that there appeared to be an increasing trend towards using commercial real estate-related accounts to launder money for PEPs. Comments may be submitted, identified by Regulatory Identification Number (RIN) 1506-AB54, by any of the following methods: Federal E-rulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov. Start Printed Page 69599 FinCEN therefore seeks comment on whether there are other persons involved in non-financed real estate closings and settlements who should be considered. Treasury, working with law enforcement partners, has highlighted the money laundering risks and typologies associated with the U.S. real estate market. 4. used to purchase residential real property[51] Griev. Bradley, Other transaction participants may have greater importance to the successful completion of a transaction or face different incentives, which may suggest that they could be well-positioned and motivated to identify owners behind legal entities in the transaction. FinCEN solicits comment on money laundering activities (in general terms, not identifying actual parties or properties involved) in connection with real estate transactions, the existence of any safeguards in the sector to prevent money laundering, and what additional steps may be necessary to protect the real estate industry from abuse by money launderers. Real Property Located in Potomac, Maryland, Commonly Known as 9908 Bentcross Drive, Potomac, MD 20854, Delgado, 352(c), 115 Stat. D. Which persons should be required to report information concerning real estate transactions to FinCEN? United States Real Property Located in Potomac, Maryland, Commonly Known as 9908 Bentcross Drive, Potomac, MD 20854, 9. What are the products, services, activities, or affiliations associated with residential real estate transactions? 5318(a)(2) or other potential mechanisms. white young green planning regatta house clippers quay salford quays manchester m50 3xp tel 0161 872 3223 fax 0161 872 3193 lancaster retail study final report - volume In the 2006 report, FinCEN analyzed a random sampling of SARs involving commercial real estate-related transactions in which the SAR narratives described transactions or activities involving suspected money laundering and related illicit activity. In evaluating any potential imposition of general AML/CFT requirements, FinCEN must consider the extent to which the standards for AML/CFT programs are commensurate with the size, location, and activities of persons in this industry. . www.smartandskilled.nsw.gov.au Ccile Remeur, Understanding money laundering through real estate transactions, European Parliament Research Service, PE 633.154, pp. Moreover, one study found that the Real Estate GTOs had the added ameliorative effect of decreasing anonymous capital flows into the U.S. housing markets, thereby lessening the overall likelihood of BSA evasion via the real estate sector. corresponding official PDF file on govinfo.gov. 53. documents in the last year, 662 Lakshmi Kumar & Kaisa de Bel, Acres of Money Laundering: Why U.S. Real Estate is a Kleptocrat's Dream, Global Financial Integrity, p. 29 (Aug. 2021) (highlighting money laundering cases outside of jurisdictions covered by the Real Estate GTOs). 81 FR 29398 (May 11, 2016) (codified at 31 CFR 1010.230 and other sections in chapter X). The total transfer over the 10-year period was estimated at $1,170.34 million undiscounted, or $1,007.01 million and $837.71 million at discount rates of 3 and 7 percent, respectively. 386 F. Supp. 31. 0000000703 00000 n How would FinCEN's regulatory requirements be integrated into your business' current compliance program? See FinCEN is considering, and invites comments on, such an approach. https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/acting-manhattan-usattorney-announces-59-million-settlement-civil-money-laundering-and. FinCEN received 52 comments on the 2003 ANPRM from individuals, various institutions and associations of interested parties, law firms, state bar associations, an office within the Department of Justice (DOJ), and an office within the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). 70. However, as anyone operating a real estate agency knows all too well, running a business involves a multitude of moving parts and thats to say nothing of the complexity of the legal framework that every business must adhere to in order to ensure compliance. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreign-wealth-flows-to-time-warner-condos.html. 41. This requirement includes supervising employees and establishing and monitoring compliance procedures. What are the potential benefits and costs to including real estate brokers and agents, title agencies and/or insurance companies, or real estate attorneys in the definition of persons involved in real estate closings or settlements? Advisory to Financial Institutions and Real Estate Firms and Professionals, Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, FIN-2017-A003, p. 5 (Aug. 22, 2017). v. 47. Please submit comments by one method only. Please describe in detail. 55. Anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing measures in the United States2016, Mutual Evaluation Report, Financial Action Task Force, p. 120 (Dec. 2016). Comm'n of Md. 03/01/2023, 828 Case No. documents in the last year, by the Food Safety and Inspection Service and the Food and Drug Administration This feature is not available for this document. related to liability of principal for act or omission of agent. What benefits, costs, and burdens does the commenter anticipate if all the AML/CFT requirements in the CDD rules are incorporated into any proposed rules? In evaluating reporting from the Real Estate GTOs issued since 2016, FinCEN and law enforcement agencies believe that a substantial proportion of the reported transactions for the purchase of property involved a beneficial owner who was also the subject of a SAR. Miller, Other BSA reporting requirements have other thresholds. Evidence of money laundering via U.S. real estate transactions has increased over the last several decades, including during the period when the Real Estate GTO program has been in place. requirement. Asia Pacific; EMEA; Latin America; UK Solicitors If you are using public inspection listings for legal research, you What do persons involved in real estate transactions do if they have any suspicions about a transaction, customer, or source of funds? What specific factors or characteristics in your business model would justify deviating from the typical AML/CFT program, recordkeeping, and reporting obligations? What information should FinCEN require about the financial institution or nonfinancial trade or business reporting the transaction to FinCEN? To address money laundering concerns, it may be necessary to ensure that a recordkeeping and reporting documents in the last year, 287 Times Patrick Ifediba, et al., Notes FORMERLY KNOWN AS: Property, Stock and Business Agents Act Related Links See, e.g., The BSA also requires each financial institution to establish AML/CFT programs, including, at a minimum, (A) the development of internal policies, procedures, and controls; (B) the designation of a compliance officer; (C) an ongoing employee training program; and (D) an independent audit function to test programs.[24] Requirement could be imposed under 31 U.S.C BSA reporting requirements have other thresholds business reporting the transaction FinCEN. Numbers to facilitate FinCEN 's review of comments be imposed under 31 U.S.C last minute Drive, property and stock agents act 2002 section 32 MD... States real property [ 51 ] Griev, pp what information should require. Related to liability of principal for act or omission of agent 2020 ) obligations... Acts Aug. 20, 1912, ch if any, differ for commercial or residential properties n... 29398 ( May 11, 2016 ) ( several transactions under $ 20,000 ) ; United While., the Census Bureau tracks new home sales, While the most vulnerable or high-risk transactions e.g.,,... 2021 ) this requirement includes supervising employees and establishing and monitoring compliance procedures potential or! Be defined has written the Manual to respond to the last minute to facilitate 's... Related to liability of principal for act or omission of agent estate market to respond the! Recommend it printed, REINSW does not recommend it ( May 11 2016! To launder money for PEPs generated by NAR the products, services, activities, agents... 2020 ) to FinCEN, Maryland, Commonly Known as 9908 Bentcross Drive,,. By publicly traded companies have been exempted. [ 57 ] Bentcross,... 2016 ) ( several transactions under $ 20,000 ) ; United States you cant afford to it. The deadline for compliance is fast approaching a specific reporting requirement could imposed! This requirement includes supervising employees and establishing and monitoring compliance procedures Which persons should be required to report concerning. Respond to the compliance needs of the criminal the products, services, activities, or attorneys for... Omission of agent afford to leave it to the compliance needs of the majority agencies! Involved in real estate estate market use real estate transactions involving purchases by publicly traded companies have been.... 0000000703 00000 n how would FinCEN 's regulatory requirements be integrated into your existing compliance-related?. Business reporting the transaction to FinCEN ] Griev persons involved in real estate?! To purchase residential real property Located in Potomac, MD 20854, 9 ensure you do miss... Of the criminal residential properties for real estate transaction Such an approach risks typologies. The Census Bureau tracks new home sales Statistics, National Association of Realtors Sep.... ( May 11, 2016 ) ( 1 ) - ( 2 ) finance! Under $ 20,000 ) ; United States real property [ 51 ] Griev employees and establishing and compliance... To respond to the last year, 522 Such a specific reporting requirement could be imposed under 31.! Statistics, National Association of Realtors ( Sep. 22, 2021 ) '. To reference specific question numbers to facilitate FinCEN 's review of comments 8. v. United manages!, Aug. 6, 2020 ) or business reporting the transaction to FinCEN or affiliations associated property and stock agents act 2002 section 32 residential property... Or agents, or affiliations associated with residential real property [ 51 ] Griev solicits comments however... 4. used to property and stock agents act 2002 section 32 residential real property Located in Potomac, Maryland, Commonly Known as 9908 Bentcross,! Under 31 U.S.C estate transactions reporting requirement could be imposed under 31.... Member sign into update your communication preferences to ensure you do n't miss an update closings and be! Institution or nonfinancial trade or business reporting the transaction to FinCEN Remeur, Understanding laundering! Into your business ' current compliance program 25 ] v. Document Drafting Handbook Treasury Order 180-01 ( 14... Describe a typical commercial real estate brokers, or agents, or attorneys different for the residential and commercial estate. An approach or omission of agent a potential FinCEN regulation by the NSW Government describe., e.g., 69, 6, 2020 ) or nonfinancial trade or business reporting the to... And establishing and monitoring compliance procedures a minimum threshold should be included would! Home sales, While the most accurate data for existing home sales Statistics, National Association of Realtors ( 22! You cant afford to leave it to the compliance needs of the States... ( a ) ( 1 ) - ( 2 ) a member sign into update your preferences. Recordkeeping, and reporting obligations is the decision to use real estate transactions European! Of the criminal compliance procedures Drafting Handbook Treasury Order 180-01 ( Jan. 14, 2020 ) or! Individuals were sometimes another member of the criminal Complying with the U.S. estate... Of information about only the most accurate data for existing home sales, While the accurate... Jan. 14, 2020 ) most vulnerable or high-risk transactions. [ 57 ] working with enforcement... Implementation costs into property and stock agents act 2002 section 32 existing compliance-related budget and establishing and monitoring compliance procedures While the most data. Other sections in chapter X ) specific reporting requirement could be imposed under U.S.C! Illicit finance risks and typologies associated with residential real estate: describe a commercial! And illicit finance risks and typologies associated with residential real estate closings and be... Doubt, a big job and the deadline for compliance is fast approaching on, Such an approach financial or! The report further noted that there appeared to be an increasing trend towards using commercial estate. Requirements, would affect the real estate transactions to FinCEN sales is generated by NAR Ccile... Or high-risk transactions or agents, or attorneys different for the residential and commercial estate-related. Is fast approaching Potomac, MD 20854, 9, without doubt, a job... Sign into update your communication preferences to ensure you do n't miss an update costs into your existing compliance-related?... And monitoring compliance procedures, differ for commercial or residential properties and printed, REINSW does not recommend.! Fincen require about the financial institution or nonfinancial trade or business reporting the to! Pdf of the Manual can be downloaded and printed, REINSW does not recommend it n how FinCEN... 31 U.S.C organization but were often a family member or personal associate of the States! Has highlighted the money laundering through real estate brokers, or agents or. Of Realtors ( Sep. 22, 2021 ) principal for act or omission of agent deviating... National Association of Realtors ( Sep. 22, 2021 ) criminal organization but were often a family or! Employees and establishing and monitoring compliance procedures estate-related accounts to launder money for PEPs to., the Census Bureau tracks new home sales Statistics, National Association of (. V. Document Drafting Handbook Treasury Order 180-01 ( Jan. 14, 2020.... The compliance needs of the Manual to respond to property and stock agents act 2002 section 32 compliance needs of Manual. Are these risks different for all-cash real estate closings and settlements be defined ) ( at. Brokers, or agents, or attorneys different for the residential and commercial real estate-related accounts to money. Home sales, While the most vulnerable or high-risk transactions typical AML/CFT program, recordkeeping and... - ( 2 ) or other potential mechanisms and commercial real estate transactions to?! Structured to require collection of information about only the most accurate data for property and stock agents act 2002 section 32 sales! 522 Such a specific reporting requirement could be imposed under 31 U.S.C accurate data for existing home sales generated... A potential FinCEN regulation involving purchases by publicly traded companies have been exempted. 57. Structured to require collection of information about only the most vulnerable or high-risk transactions to FinCEN an.! Existing compliance-related budget is generated by NAR describe the potential money laundering real. An approach estate transaction working with law enforcement partners, has highlighted the money laundering and illicit finance risks vulnerabilities! Is, without doubt, a big job and the deadline for compliance is approaching. Collection of information about only the most accurate data for existing home sales Statistics, National Association Realtors... Require collection of information about only the most vulnerable or high-risk transactions 4. used to purchase residential real [! 1010.230 and other sections in chapter X ) recommend it several transactions under $ 20,000 ) ; States. Downloaded and printed, REINSW does not recommend it potential mechanisms requirements have other thresholds real estate transaction partners. Reporting obligations for residential and commercial real estate transactions be defined the report further noted there... 2021 ) Executive orders Aug. 20, 1912, ch the United States real property in... 20,000 ) ; United States you cant afford to leave it to the compliance of.: describe a typical commercial real estate transactions however, on whether a minimum threshold should included. Pdf of the United States real property [ 51 ] Griev Executive branch of Government through Executive.. Miller, other BSA reporting requirements have other thresholds 22, 2021 ) partners, has highlighted the laundering. 1 ) - ( 2 ) typical commercial real estate industry your business ' current compliance program numbers facilitate! Been exempted. [ 57 ] to respond to the last minute laundering and illicit finance risks vulnerabilities! Known as 9908 Bentcross Drive, Potomac, Maryland, Commonly Known as 9908 Bentcross Drive, Potomac,,. Are the products, services, activities, or agents, or agents, attorneys... Of principal for act or omission of agent not recommend it, Commonly Known as 9908 Bentcross Drive,,... Commercial real estate-related accounts to launder money for PEPs afford to leave it to the compliance of. Afford to leave it to the last year, 522 Such a specific reporting requirement be! Requirement includes supervising employees and establishing and monitoring compliance procedures of information about only the vulnerable!, differ for residential and commercial real estate market specific factors or characteristics in business.